Insurance Claim Denied Due to Evidence of Multiple Collisions

An insurance dispute arose when a driver was refused coverage for car damage after evidence showed involvement in multiple collisions, contrary to her claim.

Initially, the woman filed a claim with Hollard Insurance, stating her car had collided once with another vehicle.

However, the situation took a turn when forensic data from in-car technology revealed two separate impacts occurring 11 minutes apart.

Hollard's initial acceptance of the claim was retracted following this discovery. In contrast, crash information from the other vehicle suggested the incidents happened roughly one minute apart. The insurer's expert highlighted inconsistencies in the impact heights, further pointing out that the vehicle's speed at the time of the incidents did not match the claimant's account.

The insurance policy mandated that coverage only applies to accidents resulting from a single, unexpected event. During a subsequent interview, the claimant acknowledged the possibility of additional impacts due to the car's movement post-collision, yet she was unable to provide a detailed account.

Hollard concluded that these discrepancies, along with expert analysis, indicated deceit on the claimant's part, invalidating her claim. The insured party contested the credibility of the expert report, labelling it misleading. However, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) upheld the insurer’s decision, deeming the expert findings as comprehensive and logically structured.

AFCA noted the differing time frames between the vehicles' crash data but asserted this did not undermine Hollard's position. The ombudsman stated he was unconvinced that the damage was the result of a singular accident, aligning instead with the evidence of two distinct impacts.

AFCA's ruling confirmed that regardless of whether the second crash occurred one or 11 minutes after the first, the incidents constituted separate events, leading to the denial of the insurance claim.

Published:Thursday, 14th Aug 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Rising Group Premiums Pose Challenges for Australian Life Insurance

28 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

Insurance premiums for group life policies with long-term benefits have surged between 15% to 25% on average in the first half of the year, according to a mid-year market update from Marsh Australia. While the steepest increases affected those with adverse claims experiences, short-term rates and premiums for permanent disabilities remained relatively steady. The sector has also become more selective, with insurers adopting stricter underwriting standards, particularly eschewing high-risk industries. - read more

Concerns Arise Over Construction Code Pause Amid Housing Push

28 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

The federal government's initiative to accelerate housing development by relaxing certain building regulations has raised alarm within the insurance sector. Housing Minister Clare O’Neil announced changes on social media, indicating a strategic pause on parts of the National Construction Code to expedite building approvals and encourage the construction of much-needed homes across Australia. This move comes in response to challenges in the approval process, which often delays construction. - read more

RACQ Insurance Ordered to Increase Payout After Claim Handling Flaws

27 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

RACQ Insurance has been instructed to bolster a payout to a customer following a ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA). The dispute arose after the insurer's handling of a house fire claim lodged by a woman in October 2023 was found lacking. The fire, initiated by scented candles, resulted in significant fire and smoke damage to her home. - read more

ASIC Review Puts Life Insurance Sector Under Scrutiny

26 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has spotlighted significant shortcomings in the direct sale of life insurance products, urging the industry to reassess its sales practices. The recent review unearthed ongoing issues with remuneration structures, indicating that some insurers still link commissions to sales targets, potentially fostering aggressive sales tactics. The study further revealed a troubling rise in claims disputes, with reported cases more than doubling since 2018, raising concerns about the transparency and trustworthiness of these policies. - read more

Ombudsman Sides with Insurer on Imposed Excess Dispute

25 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori

A recent ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has upheld an insurer's decision to impose an additional $2000 excess on a property policy, following a dispute raised by a policyholder over claims history impacts. - read more

Truck Insurance Articles

Essential Guide: Navigating Exclusions in Your Truck Insurance Policy

When it comes to truck insurance policies, exclusions are clauses that outline what is not covered. These are specific scenarios, conditions, or perils where coverage is denied. Understanding what an exclusion is helps you know the boundaries of your insurance, ensuring you're well-prepared against unexpected financial burdens. - read more

How to Prepare for an Insurance Claim: A Truck Owner's Checklist

If you're a truck owner, having insurance is not just a formality—it's a crucial part of protecting your assets and livelihood. The sheer size and potential risks associated with trucks make insurance indispensable. However, having a policy is only half the battle. The real challenge often comes with making a claim, where many find themselves bogged down by complexities they weren't prepared for. - read more

Understanding the Key Factors That Influence Truck Insurance Pricing in Australia

In Australia, trucking plays a vital role in keeping the economy on the move, often covering vast distances across the country. Therefore, securing the right truck insurance is not just a legal requirement but also a financial safeguard for operators and businesses. Truck insurance provides coverage for risks associated with operating commercial vehicles, protecting against damages, theft, and liability. - read more

Investing in Your Fleet: When to Buy New Trucks Vs. Repairing Old Ones

Managing a fleet of trucks is a complex endeavor that marries mechanical savvy with acute financial acumen. Every truck owner and operator in Australia grapples with the high-stakes decision of whether to invest in new vehicles or to repair and maintain their existing fleet. This predicament is not just about vehicle performance. It's a significant financial consideration that impacts the bottom line of any transport-centric business. - read more

Why truck owners need a specialist insurance broker

Truck owners require insurance cover that can protect them from unexpected financial loss. However, finding the best coverage and policies can be a daunting task, especially for truck owners who are not familiar with insurance policies and coverage requirements. This is why truck owners need the services of a specialist insurance broker who can guide them through the process of finding the right insurance coverage. - read more

Knowledgebase

Insurance Deductible:
the amount that an insured is required to contribute toward an insurance claim as stipulated in an insurance policy. Otherwise known as the "policy excess".