Horse Accident Claim Rejected: A Deeper Look into Trauma Insurance

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

The incident occurred on October 16 of the previous year, leading to a significant pelvic fracture for the claimant, followed by surgery a few days later. The woman has stated that her day-to-day activities have been severely affected as a result.

Currently, she is undergoing physiotherapy and taking medication to improve her mobility. Her orthopaedic surgeon, identified as Dr NJ, has reported that she exhibits "debilitating symptoms affecting her left leg and foot."

Despite these symptoms, Dr NJ remarked that it might take 18 to 24 months to see improvement, and confirmed that predicting a permanent condition is complex at this stage.

Clearview Life Assurance refused the claim, citing that their policy's "loss of independent existence" clause necessitates a permanent inability to perform at least two daily activities independently.

In June, the complainant's general physician noted that she requires crutches for mobility and is incapable of handling tasks such as shopping, laundry, food preparation, or housecleaning.

The claimant also stated she suffers from cognitive impairment and has not shown any nerve recovery since the incident. She contends it would be unreasonable to assume her condition will improve over time.

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) acknowledged the severity of her disability but indicated that the current medical advice suggests she could eventually recover.

"Dr NJ is in the best position to opine on the permanence of the disability, given his specialty and ongoing treatment of the complainant," AFCA noted. "He has said it's 'too early to declare a permanent condition' and has outlined the further testing and treatments that are in progress and planned."

Nonetheless, AFCA's decision leaves the door open for the claimant to present new medical evidence at a future point that might confirm the permanence of her disability.

"It may be possible for her to demonstrate with subsequent medical evidence that her disability is permanent," AFCA said. "However, based on the current evidence, I am not convinced her disability is permanent or irreversible."

This case offers a critical view into the complexities and challenges associated with trauma insurance claims and highlights the necessity for clear and definite medical proof in establishing the permanence of a condition.

Published:Tuesday, 1st Oct 2024
Author: Paige Estritori

Please Note: We do not endorse any specific products or companies. Some content is sourced from third parties, including press releases, and may not be independently verified for accuracy or completeness.

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Severe Weather Is Becoming a Bigger Truck Insurance Test

16 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori

Fresh insurance industry attention on severe weather preparation is a timely reminder for transport operators that storm, flood, hail and bushfire exposure is not just a seasonal inconvenience. For owner drivers, fleet managers and transport businesses, extreme weather can affect vehicle availability, freight commitments, depot safety, claims documentation and renewal pricing. - read more

Heavy Vehicle Law Reform Is Now an Insurance Test

09 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori

The updated Heavy Vehicle National Law framework is no longer just a future compliance milestone. With the new regime now in force across HVNL-participating jurisdictions, transport operators should treat safety management, driver fitness, maintenance discipline and record-keeping as live insurance issues, not merely operational requirements. - read more

What NSW Levy Reform Could Mean for Transport Operators

02 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori

Renewed movement on New South Wales emergency services levy reform is worth watching for transport businesses, even if the direct effect on truck insurance may not be immediate or uniform. The broader issue is affordability: when statutory charges are loaded onto insurance, they can influence whether businesses buy adequate cover, reduce limits, or leave parts of their operation exposed. - read more

Why Fatigue Management Is Again a Truck Insurance Issue

26 Aug 2026: Paige Estritori

Recent heavy vehicle compliance activity has again put fatigue management near the top of the risk agenda for Australian transport operators. While enforcement is usually framed as a road safety issue, it also has a direct insurance dimension. Insurers assessing truck insurance risk increasingly look beyond the vehicle itself and ask how well the business controls driver behaviour, scheduling pressure, maintenance downtime and record-keeping. - read more

Why Load Restraint Compliance Now Matters for Truck Insurance

19 Aug 2026: Paige Estritori

Renewed attention on heavy vehicle load restraint is a timely reminder that insurance risk does not begin and end with the truck itself. For owner drivers, fleet operators and transport businesses, the way freight is secured can influence roadside compliance outcomes, liability exposure, claim investigations and even future premium negotiations. - read more

Click for more Insurance News